Avoiding Allegory — Letting the Text Speak for Itself

How to Read the Bible Series

When God speaks plainly, we should listen plainly.
The Bible contains poetry, parables, and prophecy—but not every passage is symbolic. When we  turn literal truths into allegory without textual reason, we silence the Spirit’s intent and risk distorting God’s Word. The early Church feared this. So should we.

The Bereans searched the Scriptures daily—not for hidden meanings, but for the truth plainly revealed. The early believers, especially in the Ante-Nicene period, read the Word as it was written: historically, contextually, and with reverence. They didn’t spiritualize promises to Israel or reinterpret prophecy through philosophical systems. They let God say what He meant.

---

Scripture Focus:

“Every word of God is tested; He is a shield to those who take refuge in Him. Do not add to His words or He will reprove you, and you will be proved a liar.”
— Proverbs 30:5–6, NASB1995

---

What Is Allegorizing?

Allegorizing is taking a clear, literal statement of Scripture and replacing it with a symbolic meaning not indicated by the text itself. It often stems from:

• Philosophical systems (like those influenced by Greek thought)
• Preconceived doctrines trying to fit the text
• Attempts to “deepen” the meaning beyond what is written

While allegory is used in Scripture (see Galatians 4:24), it’s the exception—not the rule—and it’s always declared plainly.

---

When the Plain Sense Makes Sense

The Reformation principle holds true: when the plain sense makes sense, seek no other sense. God is not unclear. He doesn’t bury truth in riddles. Jesus taught in parables to conceal from the proud, but when asked, He explained them clearly to His disciples (Matthew 13:10–17).

When prophecy says Messiah will come from Bethlehem, we take it literally—because it happened literally (Micah 5:2). When the text says Israel will be restored, we should not assume “Israel” now means the Church—unless Scripture tells us so.

---

The Danger of Allegorical Interpretation

• It opens the door to subjective meaning—what the passage “means to me”
• It removes accountability to the actual words of Scripture
• It elevates the interpreter over the Author
• It can strip God’s promises of their faithfulness and precision

Many doctrines today—like Amillennialism, Replacement Theology, or covenantal reinterpretations—rest on allegory, not exegesis. That’s not how the Bereans or the early Church read.

---

How the Early Church Handled the Text

The Ante-Nicene believers read the text plainly. They looked for Christ in the Old Testament—but they did not spiritualize historical events. They held to:

• Literal interpretation unless the genre demanded otherwise (e.g., apocalyptic visions)
• A future hope based on real promises
• Reverence for God’s Word without inserting their own speculation

They didn’t assume metaphors unless the text led them there. And when symbolism was present, it was anchored in the rest of Scripture.

---

Read as a Berean, Not as an Origenist

Origen made allegory popular. Augustine expanded it. But neither approach reflects the Berean model. The Bereans didn’t search for hidden meanings. They searched for truth.

Let the Word speak. Don’t add layers that God didn’t place there. Don’t spiritualize what the Spirit wrote in plain terms. Read with humility, not imagination.

---

Return to the Word. Trust What Is Written.

We are not called to be mystical interpreters—we are called to be faithful ones. God’s Word is clear. The Spirit is our Teacher. And Jesus meant what He said.

Return to the plain meaning. Reject allegory unless the text demands it. And let God’s promises stand as He gave them—sure, specific, and Spirit-breathed.